While Carrier is already becoming an important player for the Canadiens, if not a cornerstone of their defense, it's unfortunately a completely different story for Barron.
It hasn't even been two weeks since the trade was finalized between Kent Hughes and Barry Trotz, so it's probably too early to declare a winner, even though former Ottawa Senators GM Pierre Dorion has called the trade a home run for the Habs.
However, it's hard to find any faults in this trade at the moment (from the perspective of the Montreal Canadiens).
While Carrier is a top-4 defenseman for Martin St-Louis and is playing nearly 20 minutes per game in Montreal (21:10 against Tampa Bay), Barron is off to a disastrous start in Nashville.
He continues to validate the opinions of some experts like Tony Marinaro:
And it seems like this is exactly what the Predators are beginning to realize.
In Nashville, Barron has just been demoted to the role of the 7th defenseman. He's no longer part of their regular top-6 and they're already considering sending him to NHL waivers.
In two games with his new team, Barron has played a total of 13 minutes and 6 minutes, with 0 points and a -3 differential.
The game against the St. Louis Blues was particularly disastrous, as Barron finished with a -3 differential in just 6 minutes of ice time.
It's hard to imagine a worse game for a defenseman.
In any case, we sincerely hope Barron can find his game and become the solid defenseman he has the talent and potential to be.
POLL | ||
DECEMBRE 30 | 2682 ANSWERS The Predators Are Already Making a Big Decision on Justin Barron as Things Take a Turn for the Worse Who is the best defenseman right now, in your opinion? | ||